Index

Récapitulatif des critiques déjà publiées et à venir.


* * * * * excellent
* * * * très bon
* * * bon
* * bof
* mauvais

étant donné l'importance de la musique dans le cinéma indien, j'ai évalué celle-ci entre parenthèses pour la plupart des films. La couleur rouge indique les musiques qui me paraissent incontournables.
Les films sont classés selon leur titre original ; s'il existe, le titre français est donné entre parenthèses.

langues :

A : Anglais
B :Bengali
T : Tamoul
Te : Telugu
O : Ourdou

pas de lettre : Hindi

1947 : Earth * * * * 1/2 (mus. 5 /5)
Aa Gale Lag Jaa * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Aaja Nachle * * * (mus. 3,5/5)
Aalavandhan * * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5) T
Aamir * * 1/2 (mus. 5/5)
Aan (Mangala fille des Indes) *
Abhijan (L'Expédition) * * * * * B
Alai Payuthey * * * * (mus. 4/5) T
Andaz * * *
Aranyer Din Ratri (des jours et des nuits dans la forêt) * * * * B
Arundhati * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5) Te
Asoka * * * (mus. 5/5)
Athadu * * * 1/2 Te
Awaara * * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Ayan * * * 1/2 T (mus. 3/5) T
Ayitha Ezhuthu * * * 1/2 (mus. 2/5) T
Azhagi 4/5 T


Baabul * * (mus. 1/5)
Baadshah * * * (mus. 1/5)
Baazigar * * * (mus. 3/5)
Bandini * * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5)
Bhool Bhulaiyaa * * (mus. 2,5/5)
Billa * * 1/2 (mus. 1/5) (Te)
Billu * * 1/2 (mus. 1,5/5)
Black * * *
Bobby * * *
Bombay * * * * *(mus. 4/5) T
Bombay Talkie * * * 1/2 A
Bride and Prejudice (Coup de foudre à Bollywood) * * (mus. 1/5) A
Bujjigadu * * * * (mus. 3/5) (Te)
Bunty aur Babli * * (mus. 4/5)


Chaahat * * (mus 2/5)
Chak de ! India * * * * * (mus. 2/5)
Chalte Chalte * * (mus. 2/5)
Chalti Ka Naam Gaadi * * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5)
Chamatkar * 1/2 (mus. 1,5/5)
Charulata * * * 1/2 B
Chatrapathi * * * * (mus. 4/5) Te
Chaudhvin Ka Chand * * * 1/2
Cheeni Kum * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Chingari * *
Chokher Bali * *
Chori Chori Chupke Chupke * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)


Darr * * (mus. 2.5/5)
Deevaar * * * * * (mus. 3/5)
Deewana * * 1/2 (mus. 2/5)
Devdas (1955) * * *
Devdas * * * 1/2 (mus. 5/5)
Dev D * * * * (mus. 5/5)
Dharam Veer * * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5)
Dhoom *1/2 (mus. 1/5)
Dhoom II * *1/2 (mus. 2/5)
Dil Chahta Hai * * (mus. 4/5)
Dil Kya Kare * 1/2 (mus 2/5)
Dil Se * * * * * (mus. 5/5)
Dil To Pagal Hai * * (mus. 3/5)
Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge * * * * (mus. 5/5)
Disco Dancer * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)
Don (1978) * * (mus. 3/5)
Don (2006) * * * (mus. 4/5)
Dor * * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Dostana * * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5)
Duplicate * * (mus. 3/5)
Dus * (mus 1/5)

Eeshwar (te) ?? (mus. 3,5/5)
English Babu Desi Mem * * * (mus. 3/5)
Ek Duuje Ke Liye * * (mus. 3/5)
Ek Haseena Thi * * *


Fanaa * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Fire * * *
Fiza * * (mus. 3/5)

Geraftaar * 1/2
Ghajini * * * 1/2 T
Gitanjali (Idhayathai Thirudathe) * * * 1/2 (mus 3/5) Te
Good Boy Bad Boy * (mus. 1/5)
Guddu * (mus. 1/5)
Guide * * * * 1/2 (mus. 5/5)
Guna * * * (mus. 4/5) T
Guru * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)


Haathi mere Saathi * * 1/2
Hey Ram * * * * * (mus. 3/5) T / hindi
Honeymoon Travels Pvt. Ltd. * * * * (mus. 3,5/5)
Hum Aapke Hai Kaun * * (mus. 4/5)
Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)
Humraaz * (mus. 2/5)
Hum Tum * * (mus. 1.5/5)
Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)


In custody * * * * * (mus. 4/5) O/hindi
Indian * * 1/2 (mus. 5/5) T
Iruvar * * * * * (mus. 4/5) T

Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5)
Jab We Met * * * * (mus. 4 /5)
Jalsaghar (le salon de musique) * * B
Jewel Thief * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Jhoom Barabar Jhoom * * * (mus. 3/5)
Jodhaa Akbar * * * * (mus. 5/5)
Johnny Gaddaar * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Joi Baba Felunath (Le Dieu Eléphant) * * * * B
Josh * * * (mus. 2/5)


Kaakha Kaakha * * * 1/2 (mus. 2,5/5) T
Kaadhal * * * * (mus 3/5) T
Kaagaz ke Phool * * * *
Kaala Patthar * * *
Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna* * (mus. 2/5)
Kabhi Haan Kabhi Naa * * * 1/2 (mus. 2.5/5)
Kabhi Kabhie *1/2 (mus. 3/5)
Kabhi Khushi Khabie Gham (La Famille Indienne) * * *1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Kalaba Kadhalan * * (mus. 3,5/5) T
Kal Ho Naa Ho (New-York Masala) * * * * (mus. 2.5/5)
Kandukondain Kandukondain * * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Kannathil Muthamittal * * * * (mus. 5/5) T
Karan Arjun * 1/2 (mus. 2/5)
Karz * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Kati Patang * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Khoya Khoya Chand * * 1/2 (mus 3/5)
King Uncle * (mus 1,5/5)
Khuda Ke Liye * * * * (mus. 4/5) O
Koyla * * * (mus.3/5)
Kshana Kshanam * * * * (mus. 3,5/5) Te
Kuch Kuch Hota Hai * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)


Laawaris * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)
Lagaan * * * (mus. 4/5)
Lage Raho Munna Bhai * * * (mus. 3 /5)
The Legend of Bhagat Singh * * (mus. 4/5)
Little Terrorist * * * *
Luck By Chance * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)


Main Hoon Na * * * * (mus. 2 /5)
Majunu * * * * (mus 4/5) T
Mangal Pandey * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Maqbool * * * *
Mayavi * * * (mus. 3,5/5) T
Mission Kashmir * * 1/2 (mus. 2.5/5)
Mr & Mrs 55 * * * 1/2 (mus. 5/5)
Mr Medhavi * * 1/2 (mus. 2,5/5) Te
Mohabbatein * * (mus. 4/5)
Monsoon Wedding * * * *
Mother India * * * 1/2
Mughal-e-Azam * * * (mus. 4/5)
Munna * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5) Te
Munnabhai M.B.B.S. * * 1/2 (mus. 1/5)
Muthu * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5) T
My Brother ... Nikhil * * * * (mus. 3/5)


The Namesake (Un nom pour un autre) * * B
Namastey London * * (mus. 1/5)
Nandha * 1/2 T
Naya Daur * * * * 1/2 (mus. 5/5)
Nayakan * * * * * (mus. 5/5) T
Nuvvostanante Nenoddantana * * * * (mus. 5/5) Te
No Smoking * * 1/2 (mus. 3,5/5)


Omkara * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Om Shanti Om * * * * (mus. 5/5)
One 2 Ka 4 *1/2 (mus. 3.5/5)


Paap * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Padaiyappa * * * (mus. 4/5) T
Paheli * * * (mus. 5/5)
Pakeezah * * (mus. 3 /5 )
Pather Panchali (La Complainte du sentier) * * * * 1/2 B
Pathinaru Vayathinile (16 Vayathinile ) * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5) T
Pardes * * (mus. 1.5/5)
Parineeta * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Pattiyal * * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5) T
Perazhagan * * * 1/2 (mus. 1/5) T
Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani * * 1/2 (mus. 2/5)
Pithamagan * * (mus. 2/5) T
Pournami * * * * (mus. 4/5) Te
Pratidwandi (L'Adversaire) * * * * * B
Pyaasa * * * * * (mus. 4/5)


Qayamat se Qayamat tak * * * * (mus. 4/5)
Qurbani * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)


Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi* * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Raghavendra ??? (mus. 1/5)
Raincoat * *
Raju Ban Gaya Gentleman * * (mus. 3/5)
Raju Chacha * * * (mus 2.5/5)
Ram Jaane * * 1/2
Rang De Basanti * * (mus. 3/5)
Rock on ! * * * * (mus. 3/5)
Roja * * *1/2 (mus. 4/5) T
Roti Kapada aur Makaan * * * 1/2 (mus. 2/5)

Saathiya * * * (mus. 3/5)
Saawariya * * (mus. 1/5)
Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam * * * * * (mus.5/5)
Sadma * * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Salaam Namaste * (mus. 1/5)
Salangai Oli * * * * (mus. 3/5) T
Sarfarosh * *
Satyam Shivam Sundaram* * * * * (mus.5/5)
Shakti: The Power * * 1/2 (mus. 2/5)
Shaan * * * *
Sheesha * 1/2 (mus. 1/5)
Sholay * * * * (mus. 3/5)
Shree 420 * * * ** (mus. 5/5)
Siddharta * * * (mus. 5/5 ) A (non sous-titré)
Sillunu Oru Kaadhal * * * T
Sing is Kinng * * (mus. 1/5)
Sita Sings The Blues A
Sivaji * * * (mus. 4/5) T
Suhaag ?? (mus. 3,5 /5)
Sujata * * * *
Super * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5) Te
Swades * * * * * (mus. 5/5)


Tashan * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Teesri Manzil * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
The Train * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)
Thalapathi * * * 1/2 T
Thiruda Tiruda * * * * (mus. 3/5) T


Vaaranam Aayiram * * * * (mus. 5/5) T
Varsham * * * * (mus. 4/5) Te
Veer-Zaara * * * * (mus. 5/5)
Vel * * (mus. 3/5) T
Vettaiyadu Vilaiyadu * * T
Veyil * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)T
Virumaandi * * * 1/2 T
Vivah * * (mus. 3/5)


The Warrior * * * 1/2
Water * * * 1/2 (mus. 4/5)


Yes boss * * * 1/2 (mus. 3/5)
Yogi * 1/2 (mus. 3,5 / 5) (Te)
Yuva * * * (mus. 2/5)


Zamana Deewana *1/2 (mus. 3/5)
Zinda Laash (aka Dracula au Pakistan) * * 1/2 O

et donc, pour résumer :

excellents (* * * * *) : Abhijan (l'Expédition) ; Awaara ; Bombay ;Chak de ! India ; Deewaar ; Dil Se ; Dor ; Hey Ram ; In Custody ; Iruvar ; Kandukondain Kandukondain ; Nayakan ; Pratidwandi (L'Adversaire); Pyaasa ; Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam; Satyam Shivam Sundaram ; Shree 420 ; Swades

très bons (* * * * 1/2) : 1947 : Earth ; Guide ; Naya Daur ; Pather Panchali (la complainte du sentier) ; Pattiyal ; Sadma

(* * * *) : Aa Gale Lag Jaa ; Alai Payuthey ; Aranyer Din Ratri (des jours et des nuits dans la forêt) ; Azhagi ; Bujjigadu ; Chatrapathi ; Dev D ; Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge ; Honeymoon Travels Pvt. Ltd.; Jab We Met; Jodhaa-Akbar; Johnny Gaddaar ; Joi Baba Felunath (Le Dieu Eléphant) ; Kaadhal ; Kaagaz ke Phool ; Kal Ho Na Ho; Kannathil Muthamittal ; Karz ; Khuda Ke Liye ;Little Terrorist; Main Hoon Na ; Majunu ; Kshana Kshanam; Nuvvostanante Nenoddantana ; Mangal Pandey ; Maqbool ; Monsoon Wedding ; My Brother... Nikhil ; Omkara ; Om Shanti Om ; Pournami ; Salangai Oli ; Shaan ;Sholay ; Sita Sings the blues ; Sujata ; Thiruda Thiruda; ;Varsham ; Vaaranam Aayiram ;Veer-Zaara ;

Bons ( * * * 1/2) : Aalavandhan ; Arundhati ; Athadu ; Ayan ; Ayitha Ezhuthu ; Bandini ; ; Bombay Talkie ; Chalti Ka Naam Gaadi; Charulata ; Chaudhvin Ka Chand; Cheeni Kum ; Devdas ; Dharam Veer ; Disco Dancer ; Dostana ; Ghajini ; Gitanjali (Idhayathai Thirudathe) ; Jewel Thief ; Kaakha Kaakha ; Kabhi Ha Kabhi Na ;Kabhi Khushi Khabie Gham (La Famille Indienne) ; Kati Patang ;Kuch Kuch Hota Hai ; Luck By Chance ; Mother India ; ;Muthu ; Paap; Pathinaru Vayathinile (16 Vayathinile); Perazhagan ; Qurbani ; Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi ; Roja ; Roti Kapada aur Makaan ; Tashan ;Teesri Manzil ; Thalapathi ; The Warrior ; Veyil ; Virumaandi; Water ; Yes Boss;


Pas mal (* * *) : Aaja Nachle ; Andaz ; Asoka ; Baadshah ; Baazigar ; Black ; Bobby ; Chalte Chalte ; Don (2006) ; Devdas (1955) ; Ek Haseena Thi ; English Babu Desi Mem ; Fire ; Guna ; Kaala Patthar ; Jhoom Barabar Jhoom ; Josh ; Koyla ; Lagaan ; Lage Raho Munnabhai ; Mayavi ;Mr & Mrs 55 ; Mughal-e-Azam ; Padaiyappa ; Paheli ; Raju Chacha ; ; Saathiya ; Siddharta ; Sillunu Oru Kaadhal ; Sivaji ; Yuva

Moyens ( * * 1/2) : Aamir ; Billa (Prabhas) ; Billu ;Deewana ; Dhoom II ; Fanaa ; Guru ; Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam ; Haathi mere Saathi ; Indian ; Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na ; Khoya Khoya Chand ; Laawaris ; Mission Kashmir ; Mr Medhavi ;Munna ;Munnabhai M.B.B.S ; No Smoking ; Parineeta ; Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani ; Ram Jaane ; Shakti : The Power ; Super ; The Train ; Zinda Laash (aka Dracula au Pakistan)

bof (* * ) : Baabul ; Bhulaiyaa ; Bride and Prejudice (Coup de foudre à Bollywood) ;Bunty aur Babli ; Chaahat ; Chingari ;Chokher Bali ; Darr ; Dil Chahta Hai ; Dil To Pagal Hai ; Don (1978) ; Duplicate ; Ek Duuje Ke Liye ;Fiza ; Hum Aapke Hai Kaun ; Hum Tum; Jalsaghar (le salon de musique) ; Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna ; Kalaba Kadhalan ; The Legend of Bhagat Singh ; Mohabbatein ; The Namesake ; Namaste London ;Pakeezah ;Pardes ; Pithamagan ;Raincoat ; Raju Ban Gaya Gentleman ; Rang De Basanti ; Saawariya; Sarfarosh ; Sing is Kinng ; Vel ;Vettaiyadu Vilaiyadu ; Vivah

Mauvais (* 1/2) : Chori Chori Chupke Chupke; Dhoom ; Dil Kya Kare ;Geraftaar ; Kabhi Kabhie ; Chamatkar ; Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam ; Karan Arjun ; Nandha ; One 2 Ka 4 ; Sheesha ; Yogi; Zamana Deewana

( * ) Aan (Mangala fille des Indes) ; Dus ; Good Boy Bad Boy ; Guddu ; Humraaz ; King Uncle ; Salaam Namaste .

je préfère ne pas noter : Eeshwar et Raghavendra, vus sans sous-titres (télougou) ; Suhaag : comment on note un film pareil ?

en fait j'hésite à créer une nouvelle catégorie pour guddu, en dessous de "une étoile". S'il existait une catégorie "trou noir", ce film y figurerait en bonne place.Et certains des films rangés dans la catégorie "pas mal" sont objectivement moins bons (Koyla ou Josh par exemple), mais je me suis trop amusée en les regardant pour les considérer comme mauvais.